From a Lone Librarian and Maverick Wannabe: Notes from Tammi Jalowiec, LSLS17 Student Scholarship Recipient

It was a privilege and honor to receive a scholarship to attend the 2017 Lake Superior Library Symposium in Duluth, MN, June 8 & 9. As the new lone librarian at White Earth Tribal and Community College (and University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, MLIS student), I found the speakers and topics not just interesting and timely, but extremely relevant to my current position. Keynote speaker, Dr. Loriene Roy, rightfully held the spotlight, having previously served as president of both AILA and ALA, and having direct ties to Minnesota and the White Earth Nation. However, it was a metadata and cataloging librarian that most captured my attention and spoke directly to an issue with which I’ve been struggling – inadequate, biased, and/or offensive subject headings and cataloging standards.

Catherine Oliver, from Northern Michigan University, lead one of the day’s lightening round sessions entitled, “It Says on the Label,” which briefly described the issue. She noted that although the American Library Association’s (ALA’s) interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights limits book labeling to, “viewpoint-neutral directional aids,” the Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress classifications themselves are not neutral. In fact, both systems are rife with cultural biases. (Examples: DDC has seven distinct classifications for Christianity, but only one for, “other and comparative religions”; LCC classifies Native American materials as history, separate from the whole of human knowledge.) Oliver also brought up historical denialism and described an actual record for such an item, classified as non-fiction, containing a note about the work winning an award, but nothing indicating that the contents were later proven false. Given such, “acceptable,” examples, she asked why we should not take steps to rectify these situations, especially within our local cataloging systems and standards?

Oliver continued her line of reasoning with colleagues, Violet Fox of the College of Saint Benedict/Saint John’s University and Stephen Nonte of the University of North Dakota in the breakout session, “Mavericks!: How Embracing Your Inner Nonconformist Makes Our Catalogs Better.” These catalogers suggested that libraries consider utilizing local metadata values (labels/keywords) and recommended using the following strategies:

  • Consider the unique needs of your community.
  • Consult with other librarians, instructors, and community experts.
  • Create rules, training and documentation explaining the local metadata values, including the justification behind them.
  • Review and repeat the process periodically.

I very much appreciated this perspective, which reflected the overall theme of LSLS17, “Beyond Neutral.” As librarians, we are trained to value neutrality and to defend the First Amendment. I believe it is hypocritical of us to ignore the preexisting biases within our own systems and passively wait for national or global standards to change.  I have been wrestling with these issues for some time, unsure of how to proceed. I am now inspired to be a library, “maverick,” and to take the first steps toward positive change, at least in our local catalog.

About lslsadmin

The Lake Superior Libraries Symposium (LSLS) is a conference developed by librarians from Northwestern Wisconsin and Northeastern Minnesota. LSLS was created to help librarians develop enhanced professional networks, promote resource sharing and communication between organizations, and help increase awareness of libraries and resources.

Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s